Poor Billie Frank! She's a young kid with an alcoholic single mother who
likes to take her daughter along to bars while she sings. Billie's father
has distanced himself from her, and throwing a few bills at her mother is as
close as he ever gets to his daughter. When circumstances force Billie to
lose touch with her mother for good, she's sent to a foster home. There she
meets two good friends and a love for music that stays with her as she grows
up. Years later, as an adult twenty-something woman, Billie (Mariah Carey)
and her friends Louise (Da Brat) & Roxanne (Tia Texada) have to make ends
meet by performing in clubs or being back-up singers to the untalented lead
singer of their manager Timothy Walker (Terrence Howard, who seems to be
channeling LL Cool J with his performance and flashy wardrobe).
Walker's so impressed by Billie's voice that, without telling anyone (or
giving Billie her due pay or recognition), he mixes her voice as the lead
vocal of the song being recorded at the music studio. Needless to say, the
song is a hit wherever it's played, including a '54'-like happening nightclub
where lead DJ Julian 'Dice' Black (Max Beesley) quickly sees in Billie the
type of raw talent that he can exploit to the mutual benefit of both of their
careers. After promising to pay $100,000 to Tim Walker so he can release
Billie and her friends from their contract with him, Julian introduces Billie
to the heads of CMZ Records. Would you believe that, as they work together,
Billie and Julian begin to madly fall in love with each other? And would you
believe that, upon hearing an audio cassette with Billie's songs, the record
company hands Billie and Julian a contract to produce music?
The rest of the plot of "Glitter", as directed by actor-turned-director
Vondie Curtis-Hall and co-written by Cheryl L. West & Late Lanier, is a
non-stop parade of cliche' situations that have been seen a million times
before in movies, TV shows and even children cartoons about talented nobodies
being discovered by showbiz executives. The strained friendship between
Billie and her girlfriends when Julian's love sweeps her off her feet?
Check. The pressure from record company executives to strip Billie bare of
her dignity by making her look like a slut to appeal to a wider public? An
expensive shopping spree with her girlfriends when Billie gets a credit card?
Double check. Flirting with a potentially better-suited mate when Billie
meets a talented singer/songwriter named Rafael (Eric Benet) during an awards
ceremony? Check. Billie's friends taking her back when she and Julian have
a break-up? Check. Plenty of fast-paced, quickly-edited, fly-by shots on
New York City to capture the beat of this great town? Check, check, check...
ad infinitum!
"Glitter" utterly fails to capture the magic of other rags-to-riches motion
picture fables like "Rocky" or "The Karate Kid". Blame partially goes to
director Curtis-Hall, who does a poor job of portraying the character of
Billie Frank as a fighter or an underdog worth rooting for or giving a damn
about. Carey, whose acting isn't as terrible or unwatchable as you might
think (she's no Sofia Coppola), isn't shown struggling or even caring that
much for being recognized and making it big in the music industry. How can a
movie with a lead character that has everything thrown at her feet (fame,
fortune, love, affection, media exposure, etc.) without much struggle connect
with the average man/woman that has to struggle everyday just to get by? Not
even the handful of scenes involving Billie's mother (an underutilized
Valerie Pettiford) at the beginning and end of "Glitter" make the emotional
connection between the two characters seem believable at the most basic of
human emotions: mother-daughter love.
The disconnect between "Glitter's" make-believe world and reality isn't so
insulting or insipid if the viewer takes this flick for what it is: the type
of schmaltzy and unreal Hollywood spectacle in which people are shown dancing
in the streets when a song by the movie's lead character is played on the
radio, which makes the traffic come to a halt in the middle of a busy NYC
street (pathetic!). It isn't even a 'so bad it's good' movie worth mocking
or even wasting too many brain cells thinking about, but "Glitter's" debacle
was bad-enough for Carey's record company to pay-off her contract to make the
woman go away for $20+ million dollars. Did you see that ear-to-ear smile
Carey had when she sang the National Anthem at the Patriots-Rams Superbowl
game in New Orleans last week? You'd be smiling too, if you got a
multi-million dollar payoff to go away after laying a critical/commercial egg
the likes of which Hollywood and the record industry rarely (if ever)
forget.
The Disc:
"Glitter" comes in a dreaded DVD-18 (i.e. 'flipper') format, meaning that
viewers will have a hard time just trying to look at the disc to deduct which
side they want their dose of Carey goodness coming from: the one with the
Widescreen Anamorphic transfer that preserves the film's original 2:40:1
aspect ratio, or the one with the Full Screen 1:33:1 aspect ratio. On either
selection, the picture of this movie displays close to no imperfections or
visible artifacting, edge enhancements or your run-of-the-mill picture
imperfections (not surprising considering how recent the film's theatrical
release was); there is a softness that permeates a handful of concert scenes,
fast-cut montages and 'mushy' moments of the film (like Julian's last
encounter with Timothy Walker), but they're intentional and don't detract
from the obvious production values that went into its production. There are
also subtitles in English or French for either the hearing impaired or the
clueless French movie goer wondering if "Glitter" is the American word for
"Brotherhood of the Wolves". :-)
Audio presence is strong and clear whenever "Glitter" takes place inside a
club, recording studio or concert hall (all of which give the rear and
directionality effects in the soundtrack a cue to go to work). Most of the
movie is pretty laid back and conversational though, so the English 5.1
Surround and French Surround tracks do only a serviceable (rather than
outstanding) job of capturing the musical atmosphere by playing its
soundtrack as background noise to the conversations. In the extras
department, however, "Glitter" is running on an empty tank. The
feature-length commentary by director Vandie Curtis-Hall is too complementary
and skin-deep, while also being very dry and done in a laconic delivery that
will put the average DVD viewer to sleep. Aside from a lackluster
Filmography for cast & director (which, in the case of Carey, reads more like
the discography that it is) and a promotional collection of trailers (for
"Glitter" as well as for "Center Stage" and "Dance With Me"), the only
notable extra in this DVD are the animated menus of Mariah Carey posing in
different outfits and with different facial expressions. Wooo!
bottom line:
"Glitter" isn't a horrible or despicable movie. It's just a very boring and
predictable one in which absolutely nothing happens that either surprises,
amuses or entertains the viewer (unless he/she happens to be a diehard Mariah
Carey fan). While it looks/sounds OK, we can't bring ourselves to recommend
a DVD on the strength of the quality in its picture and sound when they
belong to a film without a heart or soul worth investing one's emotions into.
By - J.M. Vargas
