An elaborate credit introduction opens "Batman & Robin" with the names of the
principal actors, the logos and the name of the movie flying around the
screen to the beat Elliot Goldenthal's menacing score (similar to the opening
of "Batman Forever"). We're then shown quick flashes of Bruce Wayne, AKA
Batman (George Clooney), and Dick Grayoon, AKA Robin (Chris O'Donnell)
suiting into their costumes and gathering their Bat gear. A couple of these
shots include too-close-for-comfort extreme close-ups of the heroes' butts
and anatomically-correct rubber suits. A few second later we're in the Bat
Cave with the heroes ready to board their vehicles. Then this exchange takes
place:
ROBIN: I want (to drive) the car. Chicks dig the car.
BATMAN: That's why Superman works alone.
"Batman & Robin" is less than three minutes old and, in an utter display of
incompetence, the first few scenes have already lost the audience by
reminding everyone of the covert homosexual undertones of the relationship
between the older man (Bruce) and the young protégé (Dick) with whom he
shares a really big house. If "Batman & Robin" had anything interesting to
show or characters worth investing our attention and emotion into the
audience would have soon forgotten about the silly introduction. But
watching Dr. Victor Fries, AKA Mr. Freeze (Arnold Schwarzenegger), trot
around in his cool car barking orders while shooting ice rays out of his gun
and sending his minions to do his deeds by playing hockey on the floor of a
frozen museum got boring really, really quick. A few minutes later Batman
and Robin survive an outer space explosion and sky surf their way to another
confrontation with Freeze in which the bad guy gets away with his loot by
freezing Robin and making Batman choose between saving his partner's life or
stopping the criminal. We know what the hero will do not only because of
movie logic, but because Mr. Freeze actually says that's what Batman will do.
Thanks Freeze, we as audience member that have been spoon-fed
good-wins-over-bad plots since birth didn't see that one coming! L
The audience is still reeling from the sight of Batman and Robin's butts in
the opening montage when it's thrown into the hippie and plant-loving world
of Pamela Isley, AKA Poison Ivy (Uma Thurman). The result of an
assassination attempt by a mad scientists colleague that happens to be
experimenting next door with a weakling called Antonio Diego, AKA Bane (Jeep
Swenson), Poison Ivy kills the man that made her what she is, takes Bane
under her watch and blows up the place. Once in Gotham City Poison Ivy tries
(as Pamela) to push her pro-environmental agenda to Bruce Wayne at the
opening of his new diamond-powered observatory, and (as Poison Ivy) she tries
to seduce Batman and Robin with her chemical powder at a charity event that
the heroes have set-up to attract Freeze. The viewing public is still stuck
thinking about the homo-erotic shots of the heroes' asses when Freeze
shows-up, meets with Poison Ivy and eventually develops with her a mutual
alliance in which they'll destroy Gotham City for their own personal reasons.
Freeze as a revenge for the death of his wife at the hands of Batman and
Robin (a clever trap set by Poison Ivy to have Freeze on the same page as
her), and Poison Ivy because her deep-rooted love affair with plant life that
she values considerably more than humans... blah, blah, blah!.
Then they happen. Three irreversible strikes in the telling of the story
that absolutely block the audience's ability to forget about being shown the
asses of the heroes. Number 1: Bruce calls his partner 'Dick', which on a
normal movie would just be the nickname of the name 'Richard' but in this one
turns into an unintentional laugh-out loud joke. Number 2: Alfred's niece
Barbara Wilson, AKA Batgirl (Alicia Silverstone), steps into the lives of the
main characters and stuns the crowds with her inability to act, look cool or
have something even remotely close to a personality. Her scenes remind
everyone watching "Batman & Robin" that they're watching a really terrible
movie which, like Pavlovian dogs, makes the entire audience flashback to the
ass shots of the opening. Heck, when Barbara finds her way into the Bat Cave
and starts dressing-up in her Batgirl outfit there's ANOTHER TIGHT CLOSE-UP
OF A RUBBER SUIT ASS. Number 3: Bruce Wayne calls Dick 'Dick' again toward
the end of the movie. That's it, the homo-erotic trauma of the ass shots got
carried all the way to end of the movie's 125 minutes. The end. Say, have
you seen the movie "Conspiracy Theory" on cable lately? J
Tim Burton departed from the producer's chair he sat on for the abominable
"Batman Forever" when "Batman & Robin" rolled around in 1997, which makes
this the first (and last) installment of the franchise that was done without
any collaboration whatsoever from the behind-the-scenes filmmakers that
worked in the first two films. Believe me, it shows! Akiva Goldsman, the
Academy Award-winning screenwriter of this year's Best Picture winner "A
Beautiful Mind", wrote this mess of a screenplay that tosses character
development, complex human emotions and silly humor at the wall some of it
sticks to the film. I guess we know now what producers didn't know then:
Goldsman writes great screenplays about mentally-ill people, NOT great
screenplays with stupid super heroes that talk/act/behave like if they're
suffering from mental illness. Unrestrained and allowed full reign of a
$100+ million budget, director Joel Schumacher crams the screen with flashy
editing, comedic sound effects, noise, CG effects and the most
anatomically-correct suits ever designed for a super hero movie (and no, that
is NOT a good thing). Love it or hate it this is a comic book movie that has
impressive set designs, outstanding photography, great special effects (no
wires!) and a sense of style that pushes the "Batman Forever" look as far as
it can be pushed with human characters.
Unfortunately all the energy and special effects in the world (which "Batman
& Robin" seem to have) can't create fear, anguish or pity from an audience
that isn't given good guys worth rooting for or criminals charismatic-enough
to make their outlandish destruction plans compelling. Arnold
Schwarzenegger's Mr. Freeze could have been a tragic figure in the same
wavelength as The Penguin's Oswald Cobblepot; Dr. Victor Fries' backstory
about his wife's illness, which the movie explores at a skin-deep level, is
dripping with potential for moral heartbreak. Instead Arnie becomes a
violent and unfunny stand-up comedian that utters one inane one-liner ('The
Iceman Cometh') after another ('If revenge is a dish best served cold then
put on your Sunday finest') after another ('Freeze in hell Batman!') and so
on and so forth. Uma Thurman's Poison Ivy is by far the weakest and
least-interesting villain of all the live-action movies, especially when she
engages in pseudo-sexual, pro-environmental psycho monologues that make
Michelle Pfeiffer's similar scenes in "Batman Returns" seem like Shakesperean
theater by comparison. Jeep Swenson's Bane (R.I.P.) fits the comic book
persona rather well, but that's not hard to do when the former wrestler's
muscles are being asked to do all the acting for him.
George Clooney does a serviceable and rather unmemorable Bruce Wayne, but at
least his scenes with Alfred are a touching reminder of their father-son
relationship. As Batman though he's asked to perform moronic shtick that's
out of place with what audiences have been led to expect from the character
(like pulling a freaking credit card out of his suit to outbid Robin for the
pleasure of Poison Ivy's company). Clooney becomes another freak in a
costume instead of a tragic human figure wearing a mask, a part that Michael
Keaton nailed down perfectly and Val Kilmer emulated rather well. Ditto for
Chris O'Donnell's Robin character, which deprived of the revenge motive of
"Batman Forever" becomes just a younger and more impulsive version of the
Dark Knight that drives a cool bike instead of a car. The prize for most
underutilized and least-interesting female character of all the "Batman"
movies has got to go to Elle McPherson's Julie Madison, who is seen in Bruce
Wayne's presence as his alleged girlfriend for a couple of scenes and then is
never heard from, seen or talked about again.
Last and certainly least there's Alicia Silverstone's Batgirl/Barbara Wilson.
She steals the oxygen in every scene she appears in... from the stench of
her nauseating non-acting persona, her stale delivery and from viewers
holding their breath in disbelief at how miscast and bland she comes across.
Holy career-going-in-a-downward-spiral-after-appearing-in-your-movie Batman!
The scene where the heroes meet Batgirl for the first time at Poison Ivy's
hideout ranks as the series' darkest hour (no pun intended) in terms of
acting, script-writing and directing. Yes, even worse than the ridiculous
ass shots, Robin yelling 'Cowabunga' and Catwoman sticking electrical juice
into Max Shreck. Put yourself in this scenario: you're Batman (i.e. older
man) and you discover that your butler's niece (i.e. troubled young girl) has
broken into your Bat Cave (i.e. apartment's secret closet) and made herself
some fancy rubber outfits (i.e. S&M gear) to hang around you and your young
companion (i.e. gay lover). How would you react?
J
To give the devil its due credit though, Akiva Goldsman's screenplay and Joel
Schumacher's direction weave into the main narrative of the movie a sub-plot
that gives Michael Gough's Alfred Pennyworth character more depth and screen
time than the other "Batman" installments. "Batman & Robin" pauses its insane
and unfocused roller-coaster of freaky bad guys and outrageous stunts every
once in a while. In those brief moments of calm we watch Alfred's
potentially-deadly illness force him to reminisce with the other residents of
Wayne Manor. These are the movie's shining moments, which glow as bright as
a comet illuminating the dark side of the moon (i.e. the rest of the movie's
flawed existence). Even Pat Hingle's Commissioner Gordon character is given
more things to do this time around like saving the lives of his men when Mr.
Freeze sets up a trap in his laboratory, or be seduced by Poison Ivy's
chemical floating hypnotic thingie (whatever) into revealing to her the
location of the Bat Signal. Two outstanding supporting performances by the
two best actors in the movie, however, aren't good-enough to prevent "Batman
& Robin" from being as bad and retarded as the most stupid episodes from the
Adam West TV show. Worst big budget super hero movie ever made? No, but
close.
The Disc:
Released on October 21 of 1997 (four months after the prequels were
released), the "Batman & Robin" DVD features the best picture and sound
transfers of the bunch by far. The English Dolby 5.1 soundtrack, in
particular, has a robust-sounding clarity and discrete panning effects that
kick in from the opening credits swooshing from all over the screen and
shaking the speakers (with the effects matching the names of the
participants) 'till the final gigantic explosion atop Bruce Wayne's
Observatory (Ch.37). Dialogue is sometimes drowned-out by the sound effects
or Goldenthal's obnoxiously loud score in the middle of an action-packed
sequence (not often but it does happen from time to time). When a movie is
as badly-written as "Batman & Robin" that's probably a good thing, especially
when Mr. Freeze is about to open his mouth and you know another retarded and
unfunny one-liner's coming. "Batman & Robin" is also the only live-action
"Batman" movie on DVD that has a French Dolby 5.1 soundtrack (the others
offer only a French Surround track). English, French and Spanish subtitles
are also available.
The video transfer is a tad less spectacular than the audio with a handful of
grain spots and dirt specs sneaking into the picture. They're tolerable
because the transfer preserves the outstanding cinematography and
wall-to-wall orgy of colorful special effects (particularly Mr. Freeze's cool
hideout and the ice emanating from his ray gun), which suck at telling a good
story but are at least pleasant to look at. Once again one disc offers a
widescreen anamorphic version of the movie while the other presents a
full-screen version. Both have the same menu/option screens which are still
a poor substitute for real bonus material, but are also better-organized,
prettier to gawk at and more informative than the DVD's of the three
prequels. The main screen even plays a subdued version of Goldenthal's
musical score while the viewer makes up his/her mind about what to select
(uhhhhh!). Aside from the always-fun Reel Recommendations
plugging other pre-'97 Warner movies on VHS the bulk of the good stuff can be
found under Special Features, which sub-divides the still
screens into 11 different categories: Cast & Crew, Bob Kane & The Birth of
Batman, Creating the New Story, Friends & Foes, Recreating Gotham City, The
Batmobile, The Redbird, The Freezermobile, Special Effects, The Costumes and
Special Make-Up.
Viewers will find quite a few sprinkles of well-organized fun facts in these
categories. They won't make the average viewer like or tolerate the idiocy
of this disaster though, and I could have lived without reading the same Bob
Kane bio for a fourth consecutive "Batman" DVD. The great picture, robust
Dolby 5.1 soundtrack and good-looking artwork used for the menu/option
screens (some of them hand-drawn) lift "Batman & Robin" from the 1.5 rating
we were tempted to bestow upon it to a still-low-but-decent 2 rating.
Terrible movie and dated DVD release, but a good-looking picture that'll also
shake your Surround system's speakers like a mofo.
bottom line:
"Batman & Robin" redefined bad acting, unfunny one-liners and lack of
character development in super hero movies when it opened (and quickly
tanked) back in '97. Akiva Goldsman is the luckiest son of a bitch in the
world and Joel Schumacher is the devil; blame these two for single-handedly
pushing the franchise's comatose corpse right into the grave. It looks and
sounds better on DVD than its predecessors, but that's a small consolation
when these pretty pictures and cool sounds belong to such an unpleasant
movie-watching experience.
By - J.M. Vargas
