NOTE: This review is from a DVD that’s part of the “Martin Scorsese Collection” Box Set. This movie can also be bought as a stand-alone disc.
As “Goodfellas” gets underway we see a trio of yet-to-be-introduced characters stab and shoot a man in cold blood in the backseat of a car, circa 1970. The movie then flashes back to 1955 to show us, through the eyes of a young and impressionable Henry Hill, how a kid could idolize and be seduced by the luxury and respect brought upon by joining the mobbed-up business in front of his Brooklyn apartment run by Paul Cicero (Paul Sorvino). By letting the audience in on the troubled times that lay ahead for young Henry Hill 15 years into the future writer/director Martin Scorsese plants the seeds of reality that will eventually intrude into Henry’s fairytale-like rise from rags-to-riches in the Italian-American mob. It’s a time-shifting cinematic technique that Quentin Tarantino would turn into an art form in his movies, but which Scorsese employed first back in 1990 to give “Goodfellas” one mother of a powerful opening sequence. It sets the tone for the 143 minutes that follow, which will most likely fly by the audience faster than any other 145 min. motion picture they’ve ever seen.
Being half-Irish (meaning he can never be fully ‘made’ into a member of the ‘family’) doesn’t stop the grown-up Hill (played by Ray Liotta in his breakthrough role) to associating with legendary tough guy Jimmy ‘The Gent’ Conway (Robert DeNiro) and hotheaded bully Tommy DeVito (Joe Pesci in a tour-de-force Academy Award winning performance). Together and their associates (who are memorably introduced in Ch. 9, a scene that has made the phrase ‘I’m gonna get the papers, get the papers’ a popular catchphrase) Henry, Jimmy and Tommy commit all sorts of brutal crimes, steal millions of dollars in cash and merchandise, become incredibly wealthy and get connected to the right people. As indicated in the opening scene of the movie though, Tommy’s violent outburst against a made man from the Gambino family named Billy Batts (Frank Vincent) and a poor kid named Spider (Michael Imperioli) eventually lead to his, and his friends, downfall into the world of drug dealing and using. And yes, I realize how ironic it is that the two characters that Joe Pesci kills in “Goodfellas” went on to become cast members for HBO’s “The Sopranos”! :-)
Henry and his wife Karen Hill (Lorraine Bracco), a Jewish gal that’s attached to her husband despite his rampant cheating and abusive behavior, survive a long stint in prison by the former and complacency of her husband’s crimes by the latter. Only when Henry’s connections with the Lufthansa heist (Ch. 33) results in a pile-up of dead associates and his own drug consumption catches up to him (Ch. 40’s classic ‘Sunday May 11th, 1980’ montage) do the tables turn and Hill desperately tries to survive long enough to remain alive. By the end of “Goodfellas” has become the very thing he mocked early in his life as a tough guy: a paycheck-earning ‘schnook’ with a 9-to-5 job that gets no respect. At least he and his wife (whom the real life Henry Hill separated from in 1989) got out of the criminal life alive and in one piece. All of Henry’s associates (Jimmy, Pauley, Tommy, etc.) were either killed or died of old age in prison.
The crown jewel of the “Martin Scorsese Collection” Box Set, “Goodfellas” has been one of the most requested DVD double-dips for what seems like ages. The story of how Henry Hill rises from childhood obscurity to foot soldier in the most powerful organized crime family of New York (and then back to being a nobody) is fertile ground for director Martin Scorsese (“Taxi Driver,” “Raging Bull,” etc.) to explore his obsession with strong men that deal with adversity in ways brought about by their upbringing, surroundings and innate self-doubts. It’s also jam-packed with lots of quotable lines peppered with amusingly profane dialogue (Joe Pesci’s classic ‘Funny Like A Clown’ scene in Ch. 10), cinematically interesting shots (the 4 min. unbroken shot of Henry and Karen walking into the Copacabana club in Ch. 13) and well-chosen music choices (Eric Clapton’s ‘Layla,’ Jerry Vale’s ‘Pretend You Don’t See Me,’ The Who’s ‘The Magic Bus,’ Sid Vicious’ punk rendition of ‘My Way,’ etc.). All that, a well-told story, brutal killings (a must for any good mobster flick) and Henny Youngman in the flesh (circa 1989) performing his classic one-liners! What more could anyone ask for?
Scripted by Scorsese and ‘Wiseguy’ author Nicholas Pileggi (with Henry Hill nearby as a consultant) “Goodfellas” is a rollercoaster ride filled with graphic violence, foul language and powerful acting by a cast of stars (DeNiro, Pesci, etc.) and then-unknown actors (Bracco, Liotta, Sorvino, Vincent Gallo, etc.) that went on to become big stars themselves following the critical success of the movie. It also set an early example for shows like “The Sopranos” and movies like “Analyze This” to juxtapose dark humor and shocking violence to complement a well-told story and good acting. Like the aforementioned “Sopranos” TV show, “Goodfellas” also gets a lot of mileage out of the lack of mobster movies/TV shows dealing with the foot soldiers of organized crime. Plenty of movies deal with the rise and fall of the leaders of the organized crime (“Scarface,” “Gotti,” “The Godfather” trilogy, etc.) but few offer as insightful, entertaining and scary look into the belly of the beast as this flick did back in 1990.
This movie also marks a sad milestone for film fans the world over. 14 years after its release “Goodfellas” continues to be regarded by many (yours truly included) as the last great movie that Scorsese has directed. “Kundun”? “Gangs of New York”? That Nicholas Cage movie in which he races around New York in an ambulance (“Bringing Up The Dead”)? Boring, mediocre and lacking (in no particular order!), and all three shadows of the greatness that Scorsese exhibits in the first 15 minutes of “Goodfellas” alone. Where has the Martin Scorsese of “Taxi Driver,” “Raging Bull” and “The Last Temptation of Christ” gone? :-(
The Disc:
For years available only in a shitty, single-layer, first-generation DVD disc that had to be flipped midway through the movie (bad Laserdisc flashbacks!), “Goodfellas” now looks much, much better than before but there are still some issues. The Widescreen Anamorphic (1:85:1) Video Transfer (which looks more like 1:78:1 to me) is consistently solid and has none of the graininess, bleeding colors or edge enhancements that plagued the original release. There are a handful of damages to the print used for this transfer (particularly a nasty vertical strip at 1:16:35 of Ch. 27) that distract, but overall the movie looks about as good as most late 1980’s stuff. The English Dolby Digital 5.1 Soundtrack is good but not outstanding; super L-O-U-D gun shots and the excellent soundtrack tunes don’t overpower the profanity-laced dialogue, but they don’t exploit the speaker separation technology as well as it could have. The loudness and clarity of the soundtrack does come through in spades though.
A Spanish Dolby Digital 2.0 Soundtrack is also included, along with English, French and Spanish Subtitles. Also on Disc 1: an Awards page listing all the awards/nominations the movie received back in 1990 and Two Commentary Tracks. The first track is assembled, Criterion Collection style, from interviews with many cast & crew members (Scorsese and his associates, the principal actors, etc.) and isn’t scene-specific. It’s an OK commentary track but the speakers tend to dwell too much on romanticized hyperboles about the meaning of working for the film and for Scorsese. When choosing this first commentary track the disc will skip scenes w/o talking, so the length of the movie is shortened by 25 min. (bravo!). The second commentary track teams-up former mobster Henry Hill (on whose life story the film is based) and the former FBI agent that sponsored Hill into the Witness Relocation Program, Ed McDonald (who plays a District Attorney in Ch. 45) and it’s pure gold. Hill’s recollections of how the events and people in the movie contrast with their real life counterparts are spellbinding. His vague description of how the real Tommy DeVito died (as opposed to the dramatized version featured in the movie) at the end of Ch. 39 sent chills down my spine! Hill also swears a lot, and is occasionally bleeped because he uses the real name of the person on which the movie’s ‘Morrie’ Kessler character is based. The many quiet dead spots in the Hill/McDonald track are worth putting up with to hear one of the most riveting commentaries to go along with a great movie that I’ve heard on DVD in a long, long time.
Disc 2 isn’t jam-packed with bonus features but the ones in it are OK. The ’Getting Made: The Making of Goodfellas’ (29:34 min.) and ’The Workaday Gangster’ Featurettes (7:57 min.) use on-location photographs, archival footage, clips from the movie and interviews with many “Goodfellas” cast & crew members (except for Scorsese, De Niro and Pesci, who speak only through clips from interviews taped in 1990) to rehash the same stories, anecdotes and thoughts heard in Disc 1’s two commentary tracks. The first featurette focuses on the making of the movie (duh!) while the second is about Henry Hill’s own personal story. The ass-kissing of Martin Scorsese by everyone interviewed in the featurette is a little too much though! A third featurette, ’Made Men: The Goodfellas Legacy’ (13:32 min.) lets six contemporary movie directors (Albert & Allen Hughes, Jon Favreau, Richard Linklater, Joe Carnahan and Antoine Fuqua) chime on about their admiration for “Goodfellas” as a piece of cinema pop culture. Like a similar featurette in the 20th Anniversary Special Edition DVD of “Scarface,” the explanation of the movie’s long-lasting appeal is skin-deep and lost amidst an overkill of reused clips from the movie.
Rounding up Disc 2’s extras are a 4:27 min. ’Paper Is Cheaper Than Film’ Featurette (split-screens of clips from the movie alongside Scorsese-scribbled drawings and notes on the script that inspired their creation) and the movie’s Theatrical Trailer. Last but not least I’d like to say that the music playing during the menu/option screens of both “Goodfellas SE” discs stinks! It sounds like generic Vegas casino music instead of something clever. From a motion picture acclaimed for its skillful mix of visuals and music, the BGM of these “Goodfellas SE” discs is a serious misfire that is made tolerable by Warner’s decision to ditch snapper cases for all its future DVD releases (hooray!).
bottom line:
One of the top (if not the very best) mobster movie of all time finally gets the royal DVD treatment it so richly deserves. Brought to life by an excellent cast of actors (De Niro, Pesci, Liota, Bracco, Sorvino, etc.) and one of the best American directors of the last half-a-century (Scorsese), “Goodfellas” tells a good story, entertains, teaches a valuable lesson and shocks the hell out of viewers with sudden outbursts of graphic violence and profanity. The DVD extras are fine (the Hill/McDonald commentary track on Disc 1 is outstanding) but the movie itself is reason alone to own a DVD player. Highly recommended.
By - J.M. Vargas